High-Frequency Switch IGBT vs. Traditional Electroplating Rectifiers: Comparative and Benefit Analysis

January 8, 2024 325 Views

In the electroplating industry, rectifiers serve as crucial equipment, and their performance directly affects electroplating quality, production efficiency, and operational costs. In recent years, high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers have gradually gained prominence in the market due to their superior performance, forming a stark contrast with traditional rectifiers such as silicon controlled rectifiers (SCR) and bridge rectifiers. This article will deeply analyze the advantages of high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers compared to traditional rectifiers and conduct a comprehensive benefit analysis.

I. Performance Advantages

(1) High Efficiency and Energy Conservation

  • WHigh Conversion Efficiency: High-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers adopt advanced IGBT high-frequency inverter soft-switching rectification technology, with an operating frequency of up to 20KHz. Their conversion efficiency is significantly improved, with the overall efficiency of the whole machine typically reaching 89% - 93%. In contrast, the efficiency of silicon controlled rectifiers is only about 70%. This means that for the same electroplating production task, high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers can convert more electrical energy into effective output, reducing energy loss during the power conversion process.
  • High Power Factor: The power factor of high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers can reach above 0.95 and remain high across the entire range. In contrast, the power factor of silicon controlled rectifiers varies between 0 - 0.9 and is usually low. A higher power factor means that the equipment can obtain more active power from the grid, with less reactive power loss. This reduces the requirements for grid capacity and also cuts down on additional electricity charges caused by reactive power.

(2) Precise Control

  • Rapid Response: The system has an extremely fast response speed, reaching the microsecond level, and can quickly react to changes in grid power and load. During the electroplating process, when the load fluctuates or the grid voltage becomes unstable, high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers can quickly adjust the output to ensure the stability of the current and voltage required by the electroplating process, guaranteeing the consistency of the coating quality. For example, in precision electroplating scenarios with strict requirements for coating thickness and uniformity, this rapid response ability can effectively avoid coating defects caused by current and voltage fluctuations.
  • High-Precision Output: The output precision can be better than 1%. Whether in constant current or constant voltage operation modes, it can precisely control the output parameters. In contrast, the constant current accuracy of silicon controlled rectifiers is less than 5%, and the constant voltage accuracy is also less than 5%. High-precision output can better meet the strict requirements of different electroplating processes for current and voltage, helping to improve product quality and reduce the reject rate.

(3) Good Stability

  • High-Quality Components: Imported brand IGBT modules are used as the main power devices, and they are equipped with high-quality components such as Schottky diodes and nanocrystalline magnetic rings, ensuring the stability and reliability of the equipment from the hardware level. These high-quality components have excellent electrical performance and anti-interference capabilities, enabling stable operation in complex working environments and reducing the failure rate of the equipment.
  • Scientific Heat Dissipation Design: High-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers are usually equipped with efficient heat dissipation systems, such as air cooling or water cooling methods, combined with a reasonable heat dissipation structure design. This ensures that the temperature of key components remains within the normal working range during long-term high-load operation, avoiding performance degradation or damage caused by overheating and extending the service life of the equipment.

(4) Small Size and Light Weight

  • High-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers do not have a power frequency transformer; instead, they use a high-frequency transformer, which significantly reduces their volume and weight. The volume is only 1/5 - 1/10 of that of SCR electroplating power supplies, and the weight is also significantly reduced. This feature makes the equipment more convenient for installation, transportation, and maintenance. At the same time, it saves installation space, providing greater flexibility for the layout of the electroplating production line.

(5) Advantages of Output Waveform

  • The output waveform is a high-frequency square wave pulse or a high-density DC square wave. This waveform can make the coating crystallization more fine and bright, enhance the adhesion of the coating, accelerate the precipitation speed, increase the current density in the dead zone of the plating tank, and improve the performance indicators of the coating, such as wear resistance, temperature resistance, and surface finish. For example, in the electroplating of precious metals like gold and silver, as well as in functional electroplating with high requirements for coating performance, the advantages of this output waveform are particularly obvious. In addition, due to the high working frequency, the adjustment of the output waveform has a relatively low processing cost, and it can be conveniently changed according to the user's process requirements to meet diverse electroplating process needs.

II. Benefit Analysis

(1) Energy Conservation Benefits

  • Take a medium-sized electroplating enterprise as an example. Suppose its monthly power consumption for electroplating production is 100,000 kWh. When using a silicon controlled rectifier with an efficiency of 70%, after replacing it with a high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifier (efficiency 90%): Monthly power savings = 100000 × (1 - 70% / 90%) ≈ 22222 kWh. If the cost per kWh is 0.8 yuan, the monthly electricity cost savings = 22222 × 0.8 = 17777.6 yuan. Annual electricity cost savings = 17777.6 × 12 = 213331.2 yuan.

(2) Production Efficiency Benefits

  • Since high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers can precisely control the current and voltage and have a fast response speed, the reject rate caused by parameter fluctuations is reduced. Assume that the original reject rate was 5%, and after using the new equipment, it is reduced to 2%. The enterprise produces 100,000 electroplated products per month, and the profit per product is 5 yuan. Then the monthly increased profit due to the reduction in the reject rate = 100000 × (5% - 2%) × 5 = 15000 yuan. The annual increased profit due to the reduction in the reject rate = 15000 × 12 = 180000 yuan.
  • Its output waveform is conducive to accelerating the electroplating speed and improving production efficiency. For example, if it originally took 10 hours to complete a batch of electroplating tasks, after using the new equipment, it is shortened to 8 hours, which is equivalent to being able to complete 25% more production tasks within the same time. If the enterprise's monthly production task is 100 batches, and the profit per batch is 1000 yuan. Then the monthly increased profit due to improved production efficiency = 100 × 25% × 1000 = 25000 yuan. The annual increased profit due to improved production efficiency = 25000 × 12 = 300000 yuan.

(3) Maintenance Benefits

  • High-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers adopt a modular design and advanced protection functions, such as overvoltage protection, undervoltage protection, overheating protection, and overcurrent protection, which greatly reduce the failure rate of the equipment. Assume that the original annual number of equipment repairs was 10 times, and the cost of each repair was 5000 yuan (including component replacement and labor costs). After using the new equipment, the annual number of repairs is reduced to 3 times. Then the annual maintenance cost savings = (10 - 3) × 5000 = 35000 yuan.
  • The equipment is small in size and light in weight, making maintenance and installation more convenient, reducing the labor and time costs required for maintenance. Assume that originally each maintenance required 2 technicians to spend 2 days, and now each maintenance only requires 1 technician to spend 1 day, and the daily salary of a technician is 300 yuan. Then the annual labor cost savings = [(2 × 2 - 1 × 1) × 300 × 7] = 6300 yuan (assuming 7 maintenance times a year).

In conclusion, high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers comprehensively outperform traditional rectifiers such as silicon controlled rectifiers and bridge rectifiers in terms of performance, and bring significant economic benefits in energy conservation, production efficiency improvement, and maintenance cost reduction. With the continuous advancement of technology and further cost reduction, high-frequency switch IGBT electroplating rectifiers will have an even broader application prospect in the electroplating industry and are expected to become the key equipment choice for electroplating enterprises to enhance their competitiveness.